Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer made a significant statement on Thursday, marking the most substantial criticism from a U.S. leader against the Israeli government since its conflict with Hamas began. Schumer called for new elections in Israel to replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Speaking on the Senate floor, Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish official in the U.S., emphasized that “the Netanyahu coalition no longer fits the needs of Israel after Oct. 7.” He highlighted a significant shift in global circumstances and expressed concern that the current governance is constraining the Israeli people due to its outdated vision.
Schumer asserted that Netanyahu has veered off course, prioritizing his political survival over Israel’s best interests. He criticized Netanyahu for showing disinterest in the establishment of an independent Palestinian state, a long-standing U.S. objective. Schumer further noted Netanyahu’s alignment with “far-right extremists” such as Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, whom he accused of contributing to a decline in global support for Israel.
Highlighting the importance of Israel’s international standing, Schumer emphasized that Israel cannot thrive if it becomes isolated. He urged for strategic adjustments in Israel’s approach towards Hamas, advocating for greater efforts to safeguard Palestinian civilians in Gaza.
Schumer stressed that innocent civilians should not suffer for the actions of Hamas, emphasizing both Israel’s and the United States’ moral responsibility to uphold humanitarian standards.
More than 1,200 individuals lost their lives in Hamas’ assault on Israel on October 7, according to reports from the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health. Additionally, an estimated 30,000 fatalities have occurred in Gaza as a result of the conflict.
“At this critical juncture, it’s evident that Israelis need to reevaluate the situation and consider whether a change in direction is necessary,” remarked Schumer. “I believe a new election is crucial to facilitate a constructive and transparent decision-making process regarding the future of Israel.”
During his speech on the Senate floor, Schumer, a vocal supporter of Israel’s right to exist, wore a yellow ribbon pin as a symbol of solidarity with hostages held in Gaza. Reflecting on the hardships faced by his Jewish ancestors in Europe, he underscored the “grave threats” confronting Israel amidst its surrounded by hostile adversaries.
Schumer voiced his backing for a temporary ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, echoing President Joe Biden’s advocacy for such a measure. He emphasized that a temporary ceasefire could facilitate the release of hostages and provide much-needed humanitarian aid to suffering Palestinians. However, Schumer opposed a permanent ceasefire, arguing that it could give Hamas the opportunity to regroup and launch further attacks on Israeli civilians.
Asserting his stance, Schumer stated, “There can never be a two-state solution if Hamas maintains significant power.”
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., criticized Schumer’s comments, describing them as “grotesque and hypocritical.” On the Senate floor, McConnell accused those who advocate for the removal of Israel’s democratically elected leader of displaying inconsistency, particularly when they express concerns about foreign interference in their own democracy.